I hesitate to write about Friday night’s dinner, because it hurts me to give La Laiterie anything but a stellar review. But I’m going to clench my teeth and do it.
Our plan was to split a burger and drink a little red wine. So we ordered a bottle of Syrah from El Dorado County (the Sierra Foothills are remarkably well-represented on the wine list). This arrived first, so we had a chance to taste it a little more carefully than we often would at a restaurant (they didn’t bring bread, an oversight which was fine with me). It smelled really nice (though it wasn’t that pronounced) of earth and dark plums—but its high (15%) alcohol assaulted the palate with what I thought was a maple syrupy sweet sensation (the wine was not actually sweet, of course—sometimes high alcohol is perceived that way), and this was balanced relatively well by medium acidity and tannins. But it was not a good accompaniment to the a “locally cured fatback” and celery salad special. I love cured pork products, and the actual fatback was really good: pure lard (no muscle mass interfering with the melting savoriness of pork fat), but the toasts it was served on were too thick and crunchy, and they tore the roof of my mouth to shreds. The fennel and celery salad tasted watery—this would be OK as an accompaniment strongly flavored pork, but the pork was just lard, and it was kind of like butter. I can imagine that the dish aimed for subtlety, but blandness was achieved. Matters were made worse by the overpowering alcohol bomb we ordered (and we have no one to blame for that but ourselves).
A small asparagus plate was tasty: a bed of a grain called farrino (?-it tasted and looked like farro) was accented by cubes of cooked prosciutto and some sort of blue cheesy sauce and topped with three spears of white asparagus. It was tasty: the farro was nutty; the sauce subtle and savory; and the prosciutto chewy, fatty, and explosively flavorful. The asparagus itself was bland. It was just steamed white asparagus, and, as far as I can tell, the difference in taste between white and green asparagus is one of degree: green is more flavorful. The prosciutto made this dish a slightly better complement than the fatback for our wine, but, of course, we went there to drink the wine with a burger.
The burger looked good—in fact, it looked pretty near identical to the last burger I had at farmstead (the best burger I’ve eaten in Providence—maybe the best burger I’ve eaten anywhere). And it tasted good. Still better than any of the other burgers in town. But every component of the burger suffered somewhat since the previous burger. The bun was drier and less flavorful (maybe it was a day old?); the shallot spread tasted bitterly of garlic; and, most importantly, the beef did not have the intensity of flavor and juiciness I remembered. We weren’t asked how we wanted the burger cooked this time (we were last time), and we forgot to say we wanted it rare. The burger was more like medium rare; this, of course, means less flavor. Finally, both the burger and the polenta frites tasted like they had sat on a shelf in the kitchen for five minutes or so before being brought to the table—not cold, but also not fresh off the grill/out of the frier. By this time, I’d decided I wasn’t really a fan of the wine, though it complemented the burger reasonably well (something more tannic would have been nice).
Drunk on Syrah, we ordered a cheese plate and a couple glasses of dessert wine. The shepherd’s wheel was runny, ripe, and creamy yet sheepy (the bloomy sheep’s cheeses I’ve had have mostly been young brebis from French supermarkets, and they have hardly any flavor); the Dutch Farmstead was a nice semifirm cow’s cheese, and a comté which was supposed to be from goat tasted an awful lot like cow—confusing but good. We ordered a deliciously dark “sticky” from Australia and a fortified dessert wine from South Africa. Both were good, but they came in ridiculously small glasses (maybe one-ounce pours). That’s silly, if you ask me.
I’m still incredibly into La Laiterie—it’s still my favorite place in Providence, but this dinner was disappointing. I did learn what not to do there: order multiple courses and have a long, drawn out meal on a Friday night. Better to keep it simple: a burger and a glass of wine, and a cheese plate to finish, on a lazy Tuesday.